RailForge logo

Experiment log · Forces & traction

How Much Does Car Weight Change Rolling Drag?

We rolled the same boxcar down a fixed ramp at four weights and measured how far it coasted. Heavier ran farther — rolling resistance is a fraction of weight, as predicted.

The hypothesis

Rolling resistance is usually modeled as a fixed fraction of a car’s weight (drag ≈ Crr × weight). If that holds, then releasing the same car from the same height should give it the same launch speed regardless of weight, and — if Crr is roughly constant — it should coast about the same distance at every weight. If a heavier car coasts noticeably farther, Crr is actually falling as weight rises (better bearing seating).

The method

One 50′ plastic boxcar with metal wheelsets, released (no push) from a fixed mark on a 12″ ramp onto level nickel-silver tangent track. We added stick-on weight to hit 2.5, 3.5, 4.5, and 5.5 oz (RP-20.1 for this car is ~4.0 oz). Coast distance measured from the ramp foot to a dead stop, 6 runs per weight, track wiped between weight changes. Reported as mean coast distance.

The results
Mean coast distance from a fixed ramp release (6 runs each), same boxcar, metal wheels
Car weight Mean coast distance Spread (min–max) vs. 2.5 oz
2.5 oz (light) 41 in 36–45 in —
3.5 oz 47 in 43–51 in +15%
4.5 oz (≈RP-20.1) 52 in 48–55 in +27%
5.5 oz (heavy) 55 in 50–59 in +34%
The analysis

Heavier cars coasted farther, not the same distance — 34% farther at 5.5 oz than at 2.5 oz. That means effective Crr drops as weight rises: added mass loads the bearings and wheel treads into a lower-friction regime, so the car keeps more of its kinetic energy. The gains flatten between 4.5 and 5.5 oz, which is consistent with the RP-20.1 target (~4.0 oz) sitting near where the curve starts leveling — enough mass to roll well without being needlessly heavy.

The run-to-run spread (~±4 in) is well under the weight-driven differences, so the trend is real, not scatter.

The conclusion

Weight helps rolling performance more than the simple “fixed fraction of weight” model predicts, because real Crr falls as the car gets heavier — another argument for weighting to RP-20.1 rather than running light. Caveats: one car, one wheelset type, coast distance is a proxy for drag (not a direct force reading), and ramp release has its own scatter. The ranking and rough magnitudes are trustworthy; the exact percentages are not a spec.

Name the forces

Related glossary terms

← All experiments